具有静态成员的 C++ 注册模式有效 "sometimes"

Question

我正在尝试在运行时实现自动 class 注册（我认为这种技术属于 "register pattern" 的名称）。在下面的示例中，我将 int 存储在静态成员向量中，但目标是存储以后可以调用的函数指针。
我的理解是，由于我下面代码中的成员 registeredClasses 被声明为 static，所以在整个程序中应该只有一个它的实例。然而，情况似乎并非如此：

classregister.h

#ifndef CLASSREGISTER_H
#define CLASSREGISTER_H

#include <vector>
#include <iostream>

class ClassRegister
{
public:
    static std::vector<int> registeredClasses; //declaration

    ClassRegister(int id) {
        std::cerr << "registering " << id << " ";
        registeredClasses.push_back(id);
        std::cerr << "new size: " << registeredClasses.size() << "\n";
    }

    //code below just for testing
    ClassRegister() {}

    static int getSize() {
        return registeredClasses.size();
    }
};

#define REGISTER_CLASS(cls) \
    static ClassRegister myClass_##cls(1);

#endif // CLASSREGISTER_H

classregister.cpp

#include "classregister.h"

std::vector<int> ClassRegister::registeredClasses; //definition

class1.h（class2.h遵循相同的模式，为简洁起见省略）

#ifndef CLASS1_H
#define CLASS1_H

#include "classregister.h"

class Class1
{
public:
    Class1();
};

REGISTER_CLASS(Class1)

#endif // CLASS1_H

class1.cpp（class2.cpp遵循相同的模式，为简洁起见省略）

#include "class1.h"

Class1::Class1()
{
}

main.cpp

#include "classregister.h"
#include <iostream>

int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
    std::cerr << "registering classes works...\n\n";

    std::cerr << "but reading from main() does not...\n";
    std::cerr << "checking size directly: " << ClassRegister::registeredClasses.size() << "\n";
    std::cerr << "checking size through function: " << ClassRegister::getSize() << "\n";
    std::cerr << "checking size on instance: " << ClassRegister().getSize() << "\n";
    std::cerr << "\n";

    std::cerr << "registration from main() uses a different register...\n";
    ClassRegister(2);
    ClassRegister(3);
    ClassRegister(4);
    std::cerr << "\n";

    std::cerr << "...which is not the one used in the header files\n";
    std::cerr << "checking size directly: " << ClassRegister::registeredClasses.size() << "\n";
    std::cerr << "checking size on instance: " << ClassRegister().getSize() << "\n";
    std::cerr << "checking size through function: " << ClassRegister::getSize() << "\n";
    std::cerr << "\n";
}

我遇到的问题是它只能工作 "sometimes"。初始输出：

registering 1 new size: 1
registering 1 new size: 2
registering classes works...

but reading from main() does not...
checking size directly: 0
checking size through function: 0
checking size on instance: 0

registration from main() uses a different register...
registering 2 new size: 1
registering 3 new size: 2
registering 4 new size: 3

...which is not the one used in the header files
checking size directly: 3
checking size on instance: 3
checking size through function: 3

我删除了 class1.cpp 和 class2.cpp，在头文件中声明构造函数，例如。 Class1() {}。注册根本不起作用：

//no output here
registering classes works...
//...

然后我恢复了更改，突然我得到了预期的输出：

registering 1 new size: 1
registering 1 new size: 2
registering classes works...

but reading from main() does not... //it does work this time
checking size directly: 2
checking size through function: 2
checking size on instance: 2

registration from main() uses a different register...
registering 2 new size: 3
registering 3 new size: 4
registering 4 new size: 5

...which is not the one used in the header files
checking size directly: 5
checking size on instance: 5
checking size through function: 5

我一直在研究这个问题，但未能弄清原因。我的猜测是它与编译顺序（但注册如何工作？）或 linkage / storage duration 有关。有人可以解释一下吗？

Answer 1

当你实现自动class注册方案时，你应该注意静态初始化顺序，多线程。

删除 .cpp 文件后它不起作用的原因是头文件未编译，因此没有人知道有任何声明。

Answer 2

我认为您在这里需要的技巧是 ClassRegister 而不是静态数据成员，而是使用具有静态局部变量的函数。这有时被称为单例，虽然我不知道这是否真的是正确的术语。

代码可能如下所示：

typedef std::vector<int> register_type;
register_type& getRegister() {
    static register_type registeredClasses; //declaration
    return registeredClasses;
}

具有静态成员的 C++ 注册模式有效 "sometimes"

C++ register pattern with static member works "sometimes"

c++

static

linkage