为什么 sql 给出的结果和不正确？

Question

tableBalance中的行数：

行 Amount 的类型为十进制 10,1

我们是 select:

SELECT
                u.UserID as UserID,

                (ifnull(b.BalanceDebit,0) - ifnull(bc.BalanceCredit, 0)) as Balance,
                ifnull(bc.BalanceCredit, 0) as BalanceCredit

            FROM 
                Users as u
            LEFT JOIN 
                    (
                        SELECT 
                            UserID,
                            SUM(Amount) as BalanceDebit
                        FROM
                            Balance
                        WHERE 
                            Operation='debit' AND StatusPay = 'success'
                        GROUP BY 
                            UserID
                    ) as b ON u.UserID = u.UserID
            LEFT JOIN 
                    (
                        SELECT 
                            UserID, 
                            SUM(Amount) as BalanceCredit
                        FROM
                            Balance
                        WHERE 
                            Operation='credit' AND StatusPay = 'success'
                        GROUP BY 
                            UserID
                    ) as bc ON bc.UserID = u.UserID

            WHERE 
                u.UserID != '12'

在 select 之后，结果我们看到下一行：

但是结果平衡不对。结果显示所有用户的余额都是 10.0，但只有一个用户 (UsersID = 40) 有 10.0.

请告诉我 sql quesry 哪里出错了？ select总和怎么对?

Answer 1

您的问题是您的第一个 LEFT OUTER JOIN：

ON u.UserID = u.UserID

应该是

ON u.UserID = b.UserID

另外，如果你想找到平衡点，我想你会把所有的贷方都拿走，然后减去所有的借方。所以不是这个：

ifnull(b.BalanceDebit,0) - ifnull(bc.BalanceCredit, 0)

不应该是这个吗？

ifnull(b.BalanceCredit,0) - ifnull(bc.BalanceDebit, 0)

Answer 2

可以使用 CASE 将两个左连接合并为一个（并修复错误的连接条件）：

SELECT
    u.UserID AS UserID,

    (ifnull(b.BalanceDebit,0) - ifnull(b.BalanceCredit, 0)) AS Balance,
    ifnull(b.BalanceCredit, 0) AS BalanceCredit

FROM 
    Users AS u
LEFT JOIN 
        (
            SELECT 
                UserID,
                SUM(CASE WHEN Operation='debit' AND StatusPay = 'success' THEN Amount end) AS BalanceDebit,
                SUM(CASE WHEN Operation='credit' AND StatusPay = 'success' THEN Amount end) AS BalanceCredit
            FROM
                Balance
            WHERE 
                (Operation='debit' AND StatusPay = 'success')
              OR
                (Operation='credit' AND StatusPay = 'success')
            GROUP BY 
                UserID
        ) AS b ON b.UserID = u.UserID

Answer 3

Bill Gregg 指出的 JOIN 条件是导致结果不正确的主要原因。可以重写查询以避免必须加入 Balance 两次：

SELECT u.UserID
, COALESCE(b.CalculatedBalance, 0)
, COALESCE(b.BalanceCredit, 0)
FROM Users AS u
LEFT JOIN
  (SELECT UserID,
    SUM(CASE Operation
      WHEN 'debit' THEN Amount*-1
      WHEN 'credit' THEN Amount
    END) AS CalculatedBalance,
    SUM(CASE Operation
      WHEN 'credit' THEN Amount
    END) AS BalanceCredit
  FROM Balance
  WHERE StatusPay  = 'success'
  GROUP BY UserID
  ) AS b
ON u.UserID = b.UserID
WHERE u.UserID != '12'

Answer 4

不需要子查询，同样的结果可以这样实现：

SELECT
    u.UserID,
    SUM(CASE WHEN b.operation = 'debit' THEN b.operation ELSE 0 END) balance_debit,
    SUM(CASE WHEN b.operation = 'credit' THEN b.operation ELSE 0 END) balance_credit,
    SUM(CASE WHEN b.operation = 'debit' THEN b.operation ELSE 0 END) -
        SUM(CASE WHEN b.operation = 'credit' THEN b.operation ELSE 0 END) balance
FROM users u
LEFT JOIN
    balance b
    ON u.UserID = b.UserID AND b.StatusPay = 'success'
WHERE u.UserID <> 12
GROUP BY u.USERID

为什么 sql 给出的结果和不正确？

Why sql give not right sum in result?

mysql

sql

left-join