模拟只读索引器属性

Question

我想知道如何模拟索引属性并且有很多关于此的问题：

How to MOQ an Indexed property
How to Moq Setting an Indexed property

等人。但就我而言，这增加了复杂性。索引属性是只读的。所以，我需要能够测试一段执行以下操作的代码

if (workbook.Worksheets.Cast<IWorksheet>().Any(
        ws => ws.Name.CompareNoCase(Keywords.Master)))
{
    ...
}

我们有以下 class 结构

public interface IWorkbook
{
    IWorksheets Worksheets { get; }
}

public interface IWorksheets : IEnumerable
{
    IWorksheet this[int index] { get; }
    IWorksheet this[string name] { get; }
    int Count { get; }
    IWorksheet Add();
    IWorksheet AddAfter(IWorksheet sheet);
    IWorksheet AddBefore(IWorksheet sheet);
    bool Contains(IWorksheet worksheet);
}

public interface IWorksheet
{
    string Name { get; set; }
}

所以在我的测试方法中，我尝试（但失败了）通过覆盖 GetEnumerator() 方法来做到这一点，因为这正是 Cast() 所调用的；我这样做如下：

List<string> fakeSheetNames = new List<string>()
{
    "Master", "A", "B", "C", "__ParentA", "D", "wsgParentB", "E", "F","__ParentC", "__ParentD", "G" 
};

List<IWorksheet> worksheetMockList = new List<IWorksheet>();
foreach (string name in fakeSheetNames)
{
    Mock<IWorksheet> tmpMock = new Mock<IWorksheet>();
    tmpMock.Setup(p => p.Name).Returns(name);
    tmpMock.Setup(p => p.Visible)
        .Returns(parentPrefixes.Any(p => name.StartsWith(p)) ? 
            SheetVisibility.Hidden : 
            SheetVisibility.Visible);

    worksheetMockList.Add(tmpMock.Object);
}

Mock<IWorkbook> mockWorkbook = new Mock<IWorkbook>();
mockWorkbook
    .Setup(p => p.Worksheets.GetEnumerator())
    .Returns(worksheetMockList.GetEnumerator());

// I can't do this as per the threads referenced above, as the property is read only.
//for (int i = 0; i < worksheetMockList.Count; ++i)
    //mockWorkbook.SetupGet(p => p.Worksheets[i] = worksheetMockList[i])...

如何模拟我的 workbook.Worksheets 只读迭代器属性？

我多了一层抽象。我需要将 IWorkbook 添加到 IWorkbooks 集合中（就像我们对 IWorksheets 所做的那样）。我没有把它放在原来的问题中，因为它只是在做与我们为 IWorksheets 所做的相同的事情，但是它不起作用。接口是

public interface IWorkbookSet
{
    ...
    IWorkbooks Workbooks { get; }
}

和

public interface IWorkbooks : IEnumerable
{
    IWorkbook this[int index] { get; }
    IWorkbook this[string name] { get; }
    int Count { get; }
    ...
}

因此，为了尝试处理这个问题，我按照下面的好答案以以下方式进行嘲笑。但是，下面的循环没有按预期工作。

List<string> fakeSheetNames = new List<string>()
{
    "Master",
    "A",
    "B",
    "C",
    "__ParentA", 
    "D",
    "wsgParentB", 
    "E",
    "F",
    "__ParentC",
    "__ParentD",
    "G"
};


Mock<IWorkbook> mockWorkbook = new Mock<IWorkbook>();
List<IWorksheet> worksheetMockList = new List<IWorksheet>();
foreach (string name in fakeSheetNames)
{
    Mock<IWorksheet> tmpWorksheetMock = new Mock<IWorksheet>();
    tmpWorksheetMock.Setup(p => p.Name).Returns(name);
    tmpWorksheetMock.Setup(p => p.Visible)
        .Returns(parentPrefixes.Any(p => name.StartsWith(p)) ? 
            SheetVisibility.Hidden : 
            SheetVisibility.Visible);

    worksheetMockList.Add(tmpWorksheetMock.Object);
}
var mockWorksheets = new Mock<IWorksheets>();
mockWorksheets.Setup(m => m[It.IsAny<int>()]).Returns<int>(index => worksheetMockList[index]);
mockWorksheets.Setup(m => m.GetEnumerator()).Returns(worksheetMockList.GetEnumerator());

mockWorkbook
    .Setup(p => p.Worksheets)
    .Returns(mockWorksheets.Object);
mockWorkbook.Setup(p => p.Name).Returns("Name");
mockWorkbook.Setup(p => p.FullName).Returns("FullName");

// This works.
foreach (IWorksheet ws in mockWorkbook.Object.Worksheets)
    Trace.WriteLine(ws.Name);

mockWorkbookSet = new Mock<IWorkbookSet>();
var mockWorkbooks = new Mock<IWorkbooks>();
List<IWorkbook> workbookMockList = new List<IWorkbook>() { mockWorkbook.Object };

mockWorkbooks.Setup(m => m[It.IsAny<int>()]).Returns<int>(index => workbookMockList[index]);
mockWorkbooks.Setup(m => m.GetEnumerator()).Returns(workbookMockList.GetEnumerator());
mockWorkbookSet
    .Setup(p => p.Workbooks)
    .Returns(mockWorkbooks.Object);

// Count is zero here??
foreach (IWorkbook wb in mockWorkbookSet.Object.Workbooks)
    Trace.WriteLine(wb.Worksheets.Count);

非常感谢。

编辑 #2：使用您的代码我有一些有趣的行为...

// Setup test.
var workbookSet = mockWorkbookSet.Object;
var actual = workbookSet
     .Workbooks[expectedWorkBooksIndex]
     .Worksheets[expectedWorkSheetIndex];

// This prints "A" - GOOD!
Trace.WriteLine("Actual " + actual.Name);

// This passes.
Assert.AreEqual(expected, actual);

// This works.
foreach (IWorksheet ws in mockWorkbook.Object.Worksheets)
    Trace.WriteLine(ws.Name);

// This works.
Trace.WriteLine(mockWorkbookSet.Object.Workbooks[0].Name);

// This does not write anything - WHY?
foreach (IWorksheet ws in mockWorkbookSet.Object.Workbooks[0].Worksheets.Cast<IWorksheet>())
    Trace.WriteLine(ws.Name);

// This fails.
foreach (IWorkbook workbook in workbookSet.Workbooks.Cast<IWorkbook>())
    Assert.IsTrue(workbook.Worksheets.Count > 0);

Answer 1

也许您正在寻找这个？

mockWorkbook.SetupGet(wb => wb.Worksheets[i]).Returns(() => worksheetMockList[i]);

Answer 2

通过使用

mockWorkSheets
    .Setup(m => m[It.IsAny<int>()])
    .Returns<int>(index => worksheetMockList[index]);

其中 It.IsAny<int>() 和 .Returns<int>(index => ...) 允许访问传递到模拟中的值您可以在 .Returns 方法中访问索引。

以下示例展示了如何设置 mocks

[TestMethod]
public void Mock_Readonly_Indexer_Property() {
    //Arrange
    var parentPrefixes = new List<string>() { "__", "wsg" };
    var fakeSheetNames = new List<string>(){
        "Master",
        "A",
        "B",
        "C",
        "__ParentA", 
        "D",
        "wsgParentB", 
        "E",
        "F",
        "__ParentC",
        "__ParentD",
        "G"
    };

    //Worksheets
    var fakeWorkSheetsList = new List<IWorksheet>();
    foreach (string name in fakeSheetNames) {
        var tmpMock = Mock.Of<IWorksheet>();
        tmpMock.Name = name;
        tmpMock.Visible = parentPrefixes.Any(p => name.StartsWith(p)) ?
                SheetVisibility.Hidden :
                SheetVisibility.Visible;

        fakeWorkSheetsList.Add(tmpMock);
    }

    var mockWorkSheets = new Mock<IWorksheets>();
    mockWorkSheets.Setup(m => m[It.IsAny<int>()])
        .Returns<int>(index => fakeWorkSheetsList[index]);
    mockWorkSheets.Setup(m => m.GetEnumerator())
        .Returns(() => fakeWorkSheetsList.GetEnumerator());
    //Assuming a Count property exists
    mockWorkSheets.Setup(m => m.Count).Returns(fakeWorkSheetsList.Count);

    //Workbook
    var mockWorkbook = new Mock<IWorkbook>();
    mockWorkbook.Setup(p => p.Name).Returns("Name");
    mockWorkbook.Setup(p => p.FullName).Returns("FullName");
    mockWorkbook.Setup(p => p.Worksheets).Returns(mockWorkSheets.Object);

    //Workbooks
    var fakeWorkbooksList = new List<IWorkbook>() { mockWorkbook.Object };

    var mockWorkbooks = new Mock<IWorkbooks>();
    mockWorkbooks.Setup(m => m[It.IsAny<int>()])
        .Returns<int>(index => fakeWorkbooksList[index]);
    mockWorkbooks.Setup(m => m.GetEnumerator())
        .Returns(() => fakeWorkbooksList.GetEnumerator());
    mockWorkbooks.Setup(m => m.Count).Returns(fakeWorkbooksList.Count);

    //WorkbookSet
    var mockWorkbookSet = new Mock<IWorkbookSet>();
    mockWorkbookSet.Setup(m => m.Workbooks).Returns(mockWorkbooks.Object);

    var workbookSet = mockWorkbookSet.Object;

    var expectedWorkBooksIndex = 0;
    var expectedWorkSheetIndex = 1;
    var expected = fakeWorkSheetsList[expectedWorkSheetIndex];

    //Act
    var actual = workbookSet
        .Workbooks[expectedWorkBooksIndex]
        .Worksheets[expectedWorkSheetIndex];

    //Assert
    Assert.AreEqual(expected, actual);

    foreach (IWorkbook workbook in workbookSet.Workbooks) {
        Assert.IsTrue(workbook.Worksheets.Count > 0);
    }

}

模拟只读索引器属性

Mock a readonly Indexer Property

.net

c#

unit-testing

moq

模拟只读索引器 属性

Mock a readonly Indexer Property

.net

c#

unit-testing

moq

模拟只读索引器属性