更改表条目没有重定向功能？

Question

我有 3 个类（猫，HouseCat:Cat，Lion:Cat）。我想做的是改变 HouseCat 的 VTable，让 HouseCat 吃肉而不是猫食。

类我使用：

class Cat
{
public:
    int age = 2;
    virtual void eat() {
        cout << "Meat" << this->age << endl;
    };

    virtual void sound() {
        cout << "Meow!" << this->age << endl;
    };
};


class HouseCat : public Cat
{
public:
    virtual void eat() {
        cout << "Cat Food" << this->age << endl;
    };
};

class Lion : public Cat
{
public:
    virtual void sound() {
        cout << "ROAR!" << this->age << endl;
    };
};

我正在尝试通过我创建的 VTable 结构编辑那些类' VTable 条目。

static void __memcpy(void * set, void * data, int size){
    DWORD old;
    VirtualProtect(set, size, PAGE_EXECUTE_READWRITE, &old);
    char*dest = (char*)set;
    char*src = (char*)data;
    for (int i = 0; i < size; i++)dest[i] = src[i];
    VirtualProtect(set, size, old, &old);
}

struct VTable{

    static VTable read(void * object){
        VTable  vt = *(VTable*)(object);
        int i = 0;
        while ((DWORD)vt.functions[i] != 0x0)
            i++;
        vt.size = i;
        return vt;
    }
    void ** functions;
    int size;

    void redirectFunction(int i, void * redirect){
        __memcpy(&functions[i], &redirect, 4);
    }
};

我确认 VTable[0] = eat()，所以我决定尝试像这样对 Vtable 进行更改：

int main(int argc, char* argv[])
{

    Lion lion = Lion();
    Cat base = Cat();
    HouseCat home = HouseCat();



    VTable lionVTable = VTable::read(&lion);
    VTable baseVTable = VTable::read(&base);
    VTable homeVTable = VTable::read(&home);
    cout << "-------------- BEFORE EDIT -----------------" << endl
    << "Base:" << endl
    << (baseVTable.functions[0]) << endl
    << (baseVTable.functions[1]) << endl
    << "HomeCat:" << endl
    << (homeVTable.functions[0]) << endl
    << (homeVTable.functions[1]) << endl
    << "Lion:" << endl
    << (lionVTable.functions[0]) << endl
    << (lionVTable.functions[1]) << endl;

    homeVTable.redirectFunction(0, lionVTable.functions[0]);


    cout << "-------------- AFTER EDIT -----------------" << endl
    << "Base:" << endl
    << (baseVTable.functions[0]) << endl
    << (baseVTable.functions[1]) << endl
    << "HomeCat:" << endl
    << (homeVTable.functions[0]) << endl
    << (homeVTable.functions[1]) << endl
    << "Lion:" << endl
    << (lionVTable.functions[0]) << endl
    << (lionVTable.functions[1]) << endl;

    pause();




    cout << "---Base---" << endl << endl;
    base.eat();
    base.sound();
    cout << "---Lion---" << endl << endl;
    lion.eat();
    lion.sound();
    cout << "---Home---" << endl << endl;
    home.eat();
    home.sound();
    cout << "---End---" << endl;



    pause();
    return 0;

}

输出了；

-------------- BEFORE EDIT ----------------
Base:
0031106E
0031121C
HomeCat:
00311285
0031121C
Lion:
0031106E
003113F2
-------------- AFTER EDIT -----------------
Base:
0031106E
0031121C
HomeCat:
0031106E
0031121C
Lion:
0031106E
003113F2

可以看到HomeCat[0]从0x311285->0x31106E

VMT.exe+11285 - E9 B6350000           - jmp VirtualMethodTable test.HouseCat::eat
[Cat Food]
->
VMT.exe+1106E - E9 ED450000           - jmp VirtualMethodTable test.Cat::eat
[Meat]

问题是函数的输出根本没有改变。

---Base---

Meat2

Meow!2

---Lion---

Meat2

ROAR!2

---Home---

Cat Food2

Meow!2

---End---

我正在使用 Visual Studio 2013。Release/Debug 也没有什么不同。

我是不是在我的代码中做错了什么，还是我缺少某种编译器的东西？

Answer 1

我同意这是一件可怕的骇人听闻的事情...但是，为了让它工作，我会尝试将您的 lion/base/home 变量更改为是指向对象的指针。现在因为它们不是指针，编译器可能会在不使用 vtable 的情况下自动调用正确的函数（因为它确切地知道对象是什么类型）。

更改表条目没有重定向功能？

Changing VTable entries doesnt redirect function?

c++

function

reverse-engineering

compiler-optimization

vmt