按在 case 表达式中带有别名的计算列排序

Question

我的 order by 子句在使用带有如下别名的计算列时出现问题：

这个 order by 没有任何问题

declare @Mode int = 1
declare @Sort nvarchar(max) = 'engname'

select top 10 School.Id          as EntityId,
              School.EnglishName as EntityEnglishName,
              School.Name        as EntityNativeName,
              case
                  when @Mode = 0 then 0
                  when @Mode = 1 then 1
                  when @Mode = 2 then 2
                  end as ActiveStudents
from V_SchoolMinimized as School
Order By ActiveStudents

以下查询有错误：

Invalid column name 'ActiveStudents'

declare @Mode int = 1
declare @Sort nvarchar(max) = 'engname'

select top 10 School.Id          as EntityId,
       School.EnglishName as EntityEnglishName,
       School.Name        as EntityNativeName,
       case
           when @Mode = 0 then 0
           when @Mode = 1 then 1
           when @Mode = 2 then 2
           end as ActiveStudents
from V_SchoolMinimized as School
Order By
    case when @Sort is null then School.Id end,
    case when @Sort = 'engname' then ActiveStudents end

如何在条件 order by 子句中使用 ActiveStudents，如图所示？

Answer 1

因此，虽然您可以在 ORDER BY 子句中使用计算列（但不能在 GROUP BY 等其他子句中使用），但您无法应用进一步的计算或条件 - 它必须准确使用创建时。

有很多方法可以解决这个问题。您使用哪种方法将归结为以下组合：

作为开发者，您更清楚哪个选项
哪个选项效果更好
哪个选项更适合您现有的查询

选项 1：重复逻辑

我不推荐这个选项，因为它违反了 DRY 原则，因此更难维护，更容易出错。

select top 10
    S.Id as EntityId
    , S.EnglishName as EntityEnglishName
    , S.[Name] as EntityNativeName
    , case
          when @Mode = 0 then 0
          when @Mode = 1 then 1
          when @Mode = 2 then 2
      end as ActiveStudents
from V_SchoolMinimized as S
order by
    case when @Sort is null then S.Id end
    , case when @Sort = 'engname' then
        case
            when @Mode = 0 then 0
            when @Mode = 1 then 1
            when @Mode = 2 then 2
        end
    end;

其余选项是 sub-query 变体，选择取决于作为开始提供的评论。

选项 2：使用派生的 table sub-query

select top 10
    S.Id as EntityId
    , S.EnglishName as EntityEnglishName
    , S.[Name] as EntityNativeName
    , S.ActiveStudents
from (
    select *
        , case
              when @Mode = 0 then 0
              when @Mode = 1 then 1
              when @Mode = 2 then 2
          end as ActiveStudents
    from V_SchoolMinimized
) as S
order by
    case when @Sort is null then S.Id end
    , case when @Sort = 'engname' then S.ActiveStudents end;

选项 3：使用 CTE（常用 Table 表达式）

with cte as (
    select *
        , case
              when @Mode = 0 then 0
              when @Mode = 1 then 1
              when @Mode = 2 then 2
          end as ActiveStudents
    from V_SchoolMinimized
)
select top 10
    S.Id as EntityId
    , S.EnglishName as EntityEnglishName
    , S.[Name] as EntityNativeName
    , S.ActiveStudents
from cte
order by
    case when @Sort is null then S.Id end
    , case when @Sort = 'engname' then S.ActiveStudents end;

选项 4：使用 CROSS APPLY

select top 10
    S.Id as EntityId
    , S.EnglishName as EntityEnglishName
    , S.[Name] as EntityNativeName
    , A.Students
from V_SchoolMinimized as S
cross apply (
    values (
        case
            when @Mode = 0 then 0
            when @Mode = 1 then 1
            when @Mode = 2 then 2
            end
    )
) as A (Students)
order by
    case when @Sort is null then S.Id end
    , case when @Sort = 'engname' then A.Students end;

注意：我建议让您的 table 别名尽可能简短，1-2 个字符，偶尔 3 个。

按在 case 表达式中带有别名的计算列排序

Order by calculated column with alias inside case expression

sql

tsql

sql-server

sql-order-by