Iseabelle 中的坏名声，如何解决

Question

当使用 Isar 证明子目标时：

sem_reg r2 v =
    {w. (Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v) = {} ∨ ℐ (reg2nfa r2 v) ≠ {} ∧ (∃q'∈ℱ (reg2nfa r2 v). ∃x∈Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v). case x of (q, q'') ⇒ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) q'' w q')) ∧
        (Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v) = {} ⟶ (∃q∈ℐ (reg2nfa r2 v). ∃x∈ℱ (reg2nfa r2 v). LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) q w x))} ⟹
    sem_reg r1 v = {w. ∃q∈ℐ (reg2nfa r1 v). ∃x∈ℱ (reg2nfa r1 v). LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) q w x} ⟹
    ¬ LTS_is_reachable (trans2Del1 r1 v ∪ trans2Del1 r2 v) (Node r1) x_ Accept ⟹
    ¬ LTS_is_reachable (trans2Del1 r1 v ∪ trans2Del1 r2 v) (Node r2) x_ Accept ⟹
    Δ' (reg2nfa r1 v) = {} ⟹ q_ ∈ ℐ (reg2nfa r1 v) ⟹ xa_ ∈ ℱ (reg2nfa r1 v) ⟹ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) q_ x_ xa_ ⟹ False

我写过这样的引理

lemma subGoal1: "sem_reg r2 v =
    {w. (Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v) = {} ∨ ℐ (reg2nfa r2 v) ≠ {} ∧ (∃q'∈ℱ (reg2nfa r2 v). ∃x∈Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v). case x of (q, q'') ⇒ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) q'' w q')) ∧
        (Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v) = {} ⟶ (∃q∈ℐ (reg2nfa r2 v). ∃x∈ℱ (reg2nfa r2 v). LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) q w x))} ⟹
    sem_reg r1 v = {w. ∃q∈ℐ (reg2nfa r1 v). ∃x∈ℱ (reg2nfa r1 v). LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) q w x} ⟹¬ LTS_is_reachable (trans2Del1 r1 v ∪ trans2Del1 r2 v) (Node r1) x Accept ⟹
    ¬ LTS_is_reachable (trans2Del1 r1 v ∪ trans2Del1 r2 v) (Node r2) x Accept ⟹
    Δ' (reg2nfa r1 v) = {} ⟹ q ∈ ℐ (reg2nfa r1 v) ⟹ xa ∈ ℱ (reg2nfa r1 v) ⟹ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) q x xa ⟹ False" 
proof -
  assume "sem_reg r2 v =
    {w. (Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v) = {} ∨ ℐ (reg2nfa r2 v) ≠ {} ∧ (∃q'∈ℱ (reg2nfa r2 v). ∃x∈Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v). case x of (q, q'') ⇒ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) q'' w q')) ∧
        (Δ' (reg2nfa r2 v) = {} ⟶ (∃q∈ℐ (reg2nfa r2 v). ∃x∈ℱ (reg2nfa r2 v). LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) q w x))}" and
    "sem_reg r1 v = {w. ∃q∈ℐ (reg2nfa r1 v). ∃x∈ℱ (reg2nfa r1 v). LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) q w x}" and a3:"¬ LTS_is_reachable (trans2Del1 r1 v ∪ trans2Del1 r2 v) (Node r1) x Accept" and 
    "¬ LTS_is_reachable (trans2Del1 r1 v ∪ trans2Del1 r2 v) (Node r2) x Accept" and 
    "Δ' (reg2nfa r1 v) = {}" and "q ∈ ℐ (reg2nfa r1 v)" and a1:"xa ∈ ℱ (reg2nfa r1 v)" and a2:"LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) q x xa" 
  then have c1:"q = Node r1" by auto
  from a1 have c2:"xa = Accept" by auto 
  from a2 c1 c2 have c3:"LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) (Node r1) x Accept" by auto
  from a3 have c4:"¬ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v) ∪ Δ (reg2nfa r2 v)) (Node r1) x Accept" by (auto simp:transEqDel)
  from c4 have c5:"¬ LTS_is_reachable (Δ (reg2nfa r1 v)) (Node r1) x Accept" by (auto simp:UnionE)
  from c3 c5 show "False" by auto
qed

但是q_好像和q不匹配。所以这个证明不能成功，如何重命名或修复它。它提到了那个坏名字 q_.

Answer 1

您处理这种情况的方式不对。复制大量文本会导致各种问题。我建议您使用 built-in 命令（本身称为“子目标”），而不是设置单独的引理并复制您的子目标的文本，这样您就可以直接访问您的本地假设。参考手册第7.2节有介绍，可以在这里下载：

https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/research/hvg/Isabelle/dist/Isabelle2021-1/doc/isar-ref.pdf

从您最初的子目标可以清楚地看出您已经陷入困境。在最后一行，我们看到名为 q_、x_、xa_ 的变量。带有尾随下划线的变量名称是一个警告，表明您存在致命的变量名称冲突，因此您一定是在到达问题顶部的子目标之前做错了什么。

Iseabelle 中的坏名声，如何解决

Bad name in Iseabelle, how to fix it

isabelle