std::thread 执行上下文 (c++14)

Question

当 std::thread 调用的函数的 in/out 变量在执行期间更改值时出现问题...

函数：

static int func(stThread_t *&pStThread)

参数

pStThread：它是一个结构，具有指向 std::thread 和其他变量（一些标志）

的指针

typedef struct stThread {
   stThread() noexcept {...};    
   stThread(const stThread &cRigth) noexcept {...};    
   stThread & operator = (const stThread &cRigth) noexcept {...};

   std::thread *pThread;
   volatile bool bBegin;
   volatile bool bEnd;

 } stThread_t;

函数func打印参数std::thread的地址 pStThread 和线程 id

func before 1785280 this_id 21968

this_thread::sleep 2 秒后，它再次打印

func afer ... this_id 21968

   static int func(stThread_t *&pStThread) {

      std::thread::id this_id = std::this_thread::get_id();

      long long p_begin = (long long)pStThread;
      std::cout << "func before " << std::to_string(p_begin) << " this_id " << this_id << "\n";
      std::cout.flush();

      pStThread->bBegin = true;

      std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(2000));

      this_id = std::this_thread::get_id();
      long long p_end = (long long)pStThread;
      std::cout << "func afer " << std::to_string(p_end) << " this_id " << this_id << "\n";
      std::cout.flush();

      pStThread->bEnd = true;

      return 1;
   };

指向 std::thread 的指针地址已更改（损坏、删除..？）

pStThread 是指针结构列表 pushing_back stThread_t

std::list<stThread_t*> listOfThreads;
listOfThreads.push_back(pStThread);

我阅读了 std::move，但不能使用指针

最后有一个线程 "garbage collector" 正在尝试擦除所有等待执行的线程。

完整代码在这里

#include <string>
#include <list>
#include <vector>
#include <map>
#include <thread>
#include <mutex>
#include <atomic>

#include <iostream>

typedef struct stThread {
   stThread() noexcept {
      pThread = NULL;
      bBegin = false;
      bEnd = false;
   };

   stThread(const stThread &cRigth) noexcept {
      this->pThread = cRigth.pThread;
      this->bBegin = (bool)cRigth.bBegin;
      this->bEnd = (bool)cRigth.bEnd;
   };

   stThread & operator = (const stThread &cRigth) noexcept {
      this->pThread = cRigth.pThread;
      this->bBegin = (bool)cRigth.bBegin;
      this->bEnd = (bool)cRigth.bEnd;

      return *this;
   };

   std::thread *pThread;
   volatile bool bBegin;
   volatile bool bEnd;

} stThread_t;

class CMain
{
public:
   typedef std::list<stThread_t*> MyList_threads;
   MyList_threads listOfThreads;

public:
   CMain() {

      std::cout << std::boolalpha << "Ex1 is move-constructible? "
         << std::is_move_constructible<stThread_t>::value << '\n'
         << "Ex1 is trivially move-constructible? "
         << std::is_trivially_move_constructible<stThread_t>::value << '\n'
         << "Ex1 is nothrow move-constructible? "
         << std::is_nothrow_move_constructible<stThread_t>::value << '\n'
         << "Ex2 is trivially move-constructible? "
         << std::is_trivially_move_constructible<stThread_t>::value << '\n'
         << "Ex2 is nothrow move-constructible? "
         << std::is_nothrow_move_constructible<stThread_t>::value << '\n';
   };

   static int func(stThread_t *&pStThread) {

      std::thread::id this_id = std::this_thread::get_id();

      long long p_begin = (long long)pStThread;
      std::cout << "func before " << std::to_string(p_begin) << " this_id " << this_id << "\n";
      std::cout.flush();

      pStThread->bBegin = true;

      std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(2000));

      this_id = std::this_thread::get_id();
      long long p_end = (long long)pStThread;
      std::cout << "func afer " << std::to_string(p_end) << " this_id " << this_id << "\n";
      std::cout.flush();

      pStThread->bEnd = true;

      return 1;
   };

   int _createThreads() {
      for (int iIdx = 0; (iIdx < 5); iIdx++) {
         stThread_t *pStThread = new stThread_t;

         pStThread->pThread = new std::thread(&CMain::func,
            std::ref(pStThread));

         if (pStThread) {
            do {
               std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(100));
            } while (!pStThread->bBegin);
            listOfThreads.push_back(pStThread);

            std::string sLog;
            sLog = "\nlistOfThreads.push_back " + std::to_string((long long)pStThread) + "\n";
            std::cout << sLog;
            std::cout.flush();
         }

         std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(1));
      }
      return 1;
   };

   int _main() {

      _createThreads();

      std::thread thread_collector([=]() {
         bool bEnd = false;
         MyList_threads::iterator it;
         it = listOfThreads.end();

         do {
            stThread_t *pStThread = NULL;

            if (it == listOfThreads.end()) {
               it = listOfThreads.begin();
               if (it == listOfThreads.end()) bEnd = true;
            }
            else it++;

            if (it != listOfThreads.end()) {
               if ((*it)->bEnd) {
                  pStThread = *it;

                  listOfThreads.erase(it);
                  it = listOfThreads.begin();
               }
            }

            if (pStThread) {
               if (pStThread->pThread) {
                  if (pStThread->pThread->joinable()) {
                     pStThread->pThread->join();

                     std::cout << " element deleted  " << std::to_string((long long)pStThread) << "\n";
                     std::cout.flush();
                  }
                  delete pStThread->pThread;
                  pStThread->pThread = NULL;
               }
               delete pStThread;
            }
            pStThread = NULL;


            std::this_thread::sleep_for(std::chrono::milliseconds(1));

         } while (!bEnd);
      });



      if (thread_collector.joinable()) {
         thread_collector.join();
      }

      return 1;
   };
};

int main()
{
   CMain _main;
   _main._main();

   return 0;
}

Answer 1

您有一个相当简单的错误，主要与线程无关：

(1) func 对 stThread_t* 进行引用。

static int func(stThread_t *&pStThread);

(2) 您传入对 pStThread

的引用

std::thread(&CMain::func,std::ref(pStThread));

(3) 这是一个局部变量，它的生命周期在循环迭代结束后立即结束

  for (int iIdx = 0; (iIdx < 5); iIdx++) {
     stThread_t *pStThread = new stThread_t;
     //...
  }

(4) 因此，当您的函数在对象被销毁后尝试访问该对象时，您会得到未定义的行为。（注意！这里，"the object"指的是有问题的指针，而不是指针指向的对象）

不清楚您为什么坚持通过引用传递 pStThread；你的函数实际上并没有修改指针（只是指向什么），而且你似乎不打算做任何这样的设备实际上有好处的事情。

std::thread 执行上下文 (c++14)

std::thread context of execution (c++14)

multithreading

pointers

c++11

stdthread

c++14